[分享] TGS 09 DEMO 評論 FM3 VS GT5

该用户已被禁言

http://www.destructoid.com/tgs-0 ... ismo-5-149770.phtml



First off, if you're looking for dirt, you won't find much here. Both upcoming racers Forza Motorsport 3 (Xbox 360) and Gran Turismo 5 (PS3) are sure to be great racing games. That said,  I think there's a clear winner here between the two high-profile racers shown on the floor of Tokyo Game Show this year. As you read on, keep in mind that we're not comparing the games themselves as much as we are the demos shown on the TGS floor.

Both were in pretty nifty setups. Gran Turismo 5 had real-world racing seats built into metal frames. Inside, players sat in front of a high-end Sony display while controlling the game with the GT steering wheel set. Forza 3 was played on a three-screen setup. They too had racing chairs and a steering wheel controller. Putting all of that aside, though, which was the better game?

Visuals:
Winner: Forza Motorsport 3
While both games look great on the track, Forza's demo featured a polish that Gran Turismo 5's lacked. The rocky hillsides and lush greenery easily showed up the bland, almost clinical-looking cityscape of Gran Turismo. Driving slow in Gran Turismo is like inviting disappointment. I guess they were hoping you'd always be moving fast enough to not notice the perfectly flat tree and pole textures. Plants and trees on the side of the road look like paper cutouts, and the tree trunks are laughably bad.  As far as the vehicle visuals go, neither game disappoints. Both supply unhealthy doses of car ***. The tighter racing action of Forza 3 made it easier to appreciate the models of the cars I raced against, but both pull off amazing feats as far as visuals go. Forza's framerate was liquid smooth, making it a bit easier on the eyes than GT5.

Control:
Winner: Forza Motorsport 3
Solely judging from the two on-floor demos,  both of which used adjustable racing seats and steering wheel rigs, Forza 3's control won the race. There was something about the balance of control that made it seem especially intuitive. I'd go as far as to say that it felt damned near flawless with the steering wheel rig they had set up at each demo station. Gran Turismo controlled great as well, with the tilt leaning farther away from arcade action and more towards realism. Nothing was notably wrong with Gran Turismo's control. It's just that the seamless feeling that we felt with the controls in Forza wasn't there in GT5.



Game play:
Winner:  Forza Motorsport 3
Both games were played on a rather easy track, and both featured racing line guidelines. Other than that, these two games play differently. Forza 3 had me racing against other AI characters that were way too easy to pass, even with the option to set the diffi***y. My choice of a medium diffi***y looked more like an easy to my eyes. I didn't try the "hard" setting, but I hope it's considerably more diffi*** than medium was. That said, some of the credit goes, again, to the seemingly flawless control of the game.

As for Gran Turismo, I watched plenty of others wipe out and give up before I played. It looked like people that had never played the series games before sat down and expected arcade racing. As always, Gran Turismo 5 had that realistic acceleration and turning that greatly contrasts to the loose, forgiving controls of other racers (Forza 3 not included, of course). I enjoy the challenge and learning curve, and prefer the rewarding stick-to-your-ribs racing that it provides. Even with that, though, Forza's gameplay was more enjoyable and approachable. It may be a bit more simple than that of GT5, but it still provides ample challenge for white knuckle racing.

If you have to have damage modeling, you want Forza 3. It's just not there in Gran Turismo. While I don't believe that it's a necessity to have damage modeling in a racing game, it is an added bonus. If you play in first-person view like I do, it's fun to see how messed up your vehicle is after a race. Gran Turismo doesn't do that. In fact, side of the road items like cones and tires don't even seem to be affected properly by impact. When I ran into a stack of tires, they seemed to float strangely in front of my car for a second before flying off to the right. I don't need true-to-life physics on these types of collisions, but this looked closer to the movement of a UFO than a stack of rubber tires.

Overall:
I'm a big Gran Turismo fan, so it was a bit of a surprise to me that the Forza Motorsport 3 demo did more for me. Things like damage modeling and background art aside, it was the superb control and high level of accessibility that won me over. Forza 3 was just more fun. More impressive. Of course, this is not to say that Gran Turismo 5 isn't a good game. It will be great, I'm sure, but Forza 3 show floor demo has me wanting to race again. I need to get me one of these three-screen setups too.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

xls00015 友情翻譯

画面方面：两个游戏都很出色，但GT5缺少FZ3所展示出来的优美的画面。如果在GT5里面慢慢的开车，你会感到就像一次令人沮丧的参观。也许GT5就想你开着快速无比的车辆，而不去注视旁边完美的平面树和人。路边的树就像一张纸片一样，树干也是令人可笑的糟糕。车体倒是一如既往的好，不像游戏里面的其它东西。黄色的车体都不咋地。紧张激励的赛车场面使得FZ3的其他车辆的模型看过去贼爽的。但应该说两者都体现出了很不错的视觉效果。FZ3则更为流畅，看过去画面更舒服。
操作：大意就是FZ3在车辆控制方面的平衡更好，更靠近人的直觉，我只能说FZ3的试玩台调较的太完美了。而GT5也很不错，更靠近真实（这句话有点难理解，FZ3更靠近直觉，而且调校完美，难道给你感觉不真实？想不通，估计还是因为是GT饭的缘故把哈哈。算了，继续）。反正就是两者给你的感觉不太一样。
游戏性方面：
大意是FZ3中等难度在我眼里也是非常容易的，没有试过最高难度。表面上看过去，游戏在难度控制上面很完美。
GT5难，操作很真实，你可以忘记其它不太专业赛车游戏的操作（当然，这其中不包括FZ3）。
总的来说，FZ3更为有趣。
如果你想要车损，毫无疑问FZ3更好。在我认为没有必要增加车辆损坏的地方，他们都增加了，很令我惊奇。GT5就缺少这一些东西，当我撞到路边的轮胎上的时候，轮胎就像UFO的移动轨迹一样，而不像是轮胎。
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IGN 評論  :

GT 5 的 Demo  
除了車體外,所有東西都是紙做的
那個所謂的車損,跟本就是騙人 !
完全沒有車損可言~最多只會掉色 !
以下為影片
http://ps3.ign.com/dor/objects/8 ... s09_gmp_damage.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[cc]flash/player.swf?videoID=32251_5411190&autoStart=false&share=true[/cc].

该用户已被禁言

一看就是枪手文，目的是为了让玩家别忘了这个世界上还有一个叫废渣3的游戏罢了

yiyou333

目前为止看视频还是觉得gt画面更好~~
fm太艳~~~

chnama

GT5 Demo你玩到了？
别更我说是两年前出品那个序章，PD有两年多的时间继续完善GT，而FM3距离发售只有不到一个月了，相信不会再有什么改善


PS：用马甲引战的人我是最鄙视的

chnama

FM3车翻了可以用方向盘转回来，我不知道那物理是怎么来的

该用户已被禁言

下面是引用chnama于2009-09-27 19:51发表的:
GT5 Demo你玩到了？
别更我说是两年前出品那个序章，PD有两年多的时间继续完善GT，而FM3距离发售只有不到一个月了，相信不会再有什么改善


PS：用马甲引战的人我是最鄙视的

只是把國外的媒體評論轉貼一下.
文不是我寫的.
要戰請跟他們戰  

爱萍

FM3的DEMO已经说明一切了，还说什么，相比FM2自然是很明显的进步，但比GT5~~~~~~~~

finalfantasy

这个。。。太有潜力了。。。。。。。。

该用户已被禁言

看来GT5还是用GT4和GTHD的贴图方式来开发的啊！

该用户已被禁言

非要出来现......